Tent Trekker

Rooftop Tent Vs Ground Tent: How to Know Which One is Best

Given the booming popularity of over-landing, road tripping, and all things off-road, it shouldn’t be surprising that more campers are gravitating towards rooftop tents, or RTTs as I prefer calling them. But how do you know which type of tent is best when it comes to Rooftop Tent vs Ground Tent.

The Rooftop sleeping tents have several advantages, including warmer sleeping during winter, cooler summertime slumber, and comfort to your outdoor aspirations.

But does that imply that everyone who loves camping should shell out the big bucks to sleep 6 feet off the ground?

In this concise guide, we’ll help you navigate the pros and cons of rooftop tent vs ground tent to help you make the best choice for your next camping adventure,

About Rooftop Tents

Rooftop tent vs Ground Tent

Rooftop tents, as their name implies, conveniently stow away on the roof of a car or the bed of a truck. These tents often fold out or pop up, allowing for effortless setup (though prior installation on your vehicle’s roof rack is necessary).

Many rooftop tents come equipped with a built-in mattress, eliminating the need for additional sleeping pads when you embark on your adventure.

Typically, rooftop tents have a ladder that facilitates easy access to the sleeping area. These tents are commonly mounted on 4X4 expedition or over-landing vehicles, ensuring a secure and elevated camping experience.

Rooftop Tents Come in Three Main Styles;

●      Hard Shell Rooftop

These tents have a durable, rigid shell made of materials like aluminum, fiberglass, or hard plastic. They offer excellent protection against the sun and other elements since they include a UV coating.

The drawbacks of this rooftop tent include their higher cost and limited capacity—honestly, only one or two people can fit in.

●      Soft-shell Rooftop

Soft-shell tents have a fabric body and a collapsible frame. They are generally lighter and more compact than hard-shell tents, making them easier to transport.

What draws me to this tent is its smaller footprint when you fold it away and larger footprint when it pops out.

With an annex, this tent is spacious and, most importantly, comfy enough to accommodate you, your family, and even a furry companion.

If you prefer a “pack and go” style of tent, this is the one for you.

●      Hybrid Rooftop

A hybrid rooftop tent combines the best of both worlds (hard and soft shell tents).

While featuring durability, compact storage, and additional roof cargo space provided by the hard shell, this unique design offers the added sleeping space provided by the soft shell.

About Ground Tents

Family Ground Tent

Not every camper wants to sleep on their rig’s roof, and ground tents make perfect sense.

As the name suggests, you pitch these tents on the ground. Over the years, ground tents have significantly improved, resulting in hassle-free setups for the best models.

Today, most ground tents utilize lightweight materials, making them easier to handle during setup and transportation.

Furthermore, the wide variety of designs caters to individuals with diverse preferences and budgets, ensuring there is an ideal option for every camper.

Some of the Ground Tent designs include:

  • Dome tents
  • Cabin tents
  • Tunnel tents
  • Frame tents
  • Backpacking tents
  • Pop-up tents
  • Inflatable tents
  • Geodesic and semi-geodesic tents

Advantages of Rooftop Tents

Well, rooftop tents basically turn your car into a tree-house which I believe most of us enjoyed climbing at some point.

      We can all agree that there is an added thrill to sleeping on an elevated platform compared to crawling into a ground tent (not that there’s anything wrong with ground tents).

      And nothing beats the breathtaking views you experience from a rooftop tent.

      Rooftop tents offer an unparalleled opportunity to immerse yourself in the beauty of nature, allowing you to savor the awe-inspiring sights right from your elevated perch.

      Thanks to the elevated positioning of a rooftop tent, you can set up camp in any terrain.

      Whether the ground is uneven, soft, and muddy or covered in large, sharp gravel, you can rest assured that your tent, securely positioned several feet above the ground, will keep you warm and dry.

      It’s like being in a tree fort equipped with a comfortable foam mattress and a waterproof roof.

      Rooftop tents offer an incredibly comfortable camping setup that helps to keep bugs and animals at bay.

      By elevating your sleeping quarters off the ground, you create a barrier that minimizes the chances of unwanted visitors during the night.

      And here comes the best part, with the explosion in rooftop tents interest, there are now several options, and these tents are available for almost any car, setting, and need (yes, even campers out there with the Porsche 911).

      Downsides of a Rooftop Tent

      Small Rooftop tent

      Rooftop tents add weight and height to your vehicle, potentially affecting fuel efficiency and maneuverability.

      The added weight may also impact the vehicle’s handling, especially during off-road or challenging driving conditions.

      The additional features, materials, and engineering required for a sturdy and reliable rooftop setup contribute to the higher price tag.

      Due to their elevated position, rooftop tents can be more exposed to wind, especially in open and exposed camping locations.

      As a result, you can experience increased noise, reduced stability, and potential discomfort during windy conditions.

      Advantages of Ground Tents

      The latest ground tents can almost be set up effortlessly and independently, you no longer need to struggle with poles, especially in the dark.

      Some ground tents even utilize self-supporting or freestanding designs, which means they can stand up independently without additional stakes or guy lines.

      This simplifies the setup process and allows for greater flexibility in choosing a campsite.

      Beyond ease of setup, ground tents offer the advantage of allowing you to set up then freely venture off for further exploration.

      Moreover, ground tents often provide walk-in, ample space, and room for multiple occupants, making them ideal for group camping or family trips.

      Tents are now lightweight, making them highly suitable for backpackers who embark on long hikes, carrying their packs for extended periods.

      With ground tents, there is something for everyone. These tents come at various affordable prices, making them accessible to campers with different budget considerations.

      Downsides of Ground Tents

      Ground tents are more susceptible to adverse weather conditions.

      Strong winds and heavy rain can potentially lead to water seepage or flooding inside the tent, compromising your comfort and protection.

      It’s also worth considering that ground tents might be more prone to visits from curious animals or insects.

      Key Differences Between Rooftop Tent vs Ground Tent

      Setup

      Regarding ease of setup, rooftop tents often win hands down.

      With a rooftop tent, you install the bulk part at home with the first attachment to the roof rack. Later in your camping site, setup drops to just a few minutes or less.

      What you’ll love about the set up of rooftop tents is that you can leave your bedding in place when you fold up the tent. This saves time and hassle when you set up and tear down camp. A small BUT though: you’ll require a ladder to access the rooftop tent.

      Most ground tents typically take between 10 and 30 minutes to set up. However, if you’re searching for a ground tent that’s easy and quick to set up, nothing matches an instant pop-up tent.

      Note: ground tents offer easy entry and exit without climbing.

      Comfort and Security Rooftop Tent vs Ground Tent

      Ground Tent in Mountains

      The peace of mind and restful sleep offered by a rooftop tent are truly priceless when facing the unpredictable forces of nature. You won’t wake up to a hyena rooting around since out of its line of sight. However, the interior living space may be limited compared to larger ground tents.

      Ground tents often provide more interior living space, allowing additional gear storage. They can accommodate larger groups and provide more room for movement.

      But they won’t secure you from insects and animals at night or a drunk camper who might decide to run you over.

      Durability of Rooftop Tent vs Ground Tent

      Generally, rooftop tents last longer than ground tents since they are made from thicker and stronger materials.

      They also have more robust, thicker zippers, poles, and flooring. Rooftop tents can withstand up to ten years of use and abuse.

      On the other hand, ground tents frequently only survive five years.

      Cost Rooftop Tent vs Ground Tent

      Compared to ground tents, rooftop tents are significantly more expensive. Quality soft-shell models cost between $1000 and $1500, whereas hard-shells run between $1500 to $3500.

      Some tents don’t have a ladder, so you may need to buy one. That’s not all; you must modify your vehicle, which means extra weight, hence more fuel consumption. As you can see, expenses add up quickly.

      For roughly $100, you can purchase a good 1 or 2-person ground tent. And if you’re on a tight budget, you can go for an entry-level tent for approximately $30.

      The modest ground tent has stood the test of time, and for a good reason: they are reasonably priced and available in various forms and sizes. But their quality and durability can’t match that of rooftop tents.

      Rooftop Tent vs Ground Tent-In Conclusion

      Both rooftop tent vs ground tent come with their unique sets of advantages and disadvantages. By examining their respective characteristics, it becomes evident that each option has merits and drawbacks.

      Understanding these differences can help you make an informed decision based on your specific camping needs and preferences.

      Scroll to Top